[MediaWiki-l] Reorganizing your wiki when the whole world changes...?

Stip stipen.treublatt at gmx.net
Thu Nov 20 08:28:03 UTC 2014


-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

Then maybe you should tag each article with a "Version"-template,
which specifies for which structure the article was written and adds
an appriopriate category. I recently saw this being used at
http://www.ckiiwiki.com/Template:Version

Am 19.11.2014 16:59, schrieb Daniel Barrett:
> Greg Rundlett (freephile) suggests:
>> The Replace Text extension works pretty well, and even warns
>> about conversions that can't be undone [1]
>> >http://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Extension:Replace_Text  Perhaps
>> that's what you're referring to when you mention automatic search
>> and replace.
> 
> Thanks Greg. I've used ReplaceText and it's pretty handy. We also
> use Pywikibot for similar things. However, these are one-to-one
> syntactic changes. The example I gave -- of revamping the periodic
> table of the elements, analogous to a company reorg -- requires
> more intelligence. I'm not talking about Hydrogen being renamed to
> "Bydrogen."  I'm talking about a paradigm shift in chemistry in
> which the old elements have been replaced by new *concepts*, not
> just new names. Instead of "elements" we now have "Foobles" that
> don't correspond one-to-one with the old elements. That's what
> happens in a corporate reorganization: team names don't just
> change. People are shuffled into an entirely new organizational
> shape. A company that was formerly organized by geography (USA,
> Europe, Asia) gets reorganized by function (Global Sales, Global
> Technology, Global Human Resources). In one second, all your wiki
> content about company structure becomes deeply wrong.
> 
> In some ways, this is the wiki equivalent of database schema
> evolution, in which one set of organized data must be transformed
> into another. It's a very, very hard problem. I was wondering if
> anybody has successfully handled it.
> 
>> One thing I do is to create and use templates like
>> {{CompanyName}}, {{PrimaryDomain}}, {{EngineeringTeam}} so that
>> you can use them throughout the wiki and update the template...
> 
> We did this too, years ago, creating a {{CompanyName }} template.
> And then something amazing happened. Our company split into TWO
> companies, a parent and a subsidiary. Now, human intelligence is
> required to change each instance of {{CompanyName}} either to
> {{ParentCompany}} or {{ChildCompany}}. No automation can do this,
> short of A.I.
> 
> DanB
> 
> ________________________________ My email address has changed to
> danb at cimpress.com. Please update your address book.
> 
> Cimpress is the new name for Vistaprint NV, the world’s leader in
> mass customization. Read more about Cimpress at www.cimpress.com. 
> ________________________________ 
> _______________________________________________ MediaWiki-l mailing
> list To unsubscribe, go to: 
> https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/mediawiki-l
> 
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v2.0.22 (MingW32)
Comment: Using GnuPG with Thunderbird - http://www.enigmail.net/

iQEcBAEBAgAGBQJUbaYSAAoJEK8msiPibiwtBrQH/AgNKUbgiZkS89HiWHNOrSWY
UOemcC+P6WEpiy3nury1IvvlA+u9CbR8l2epaLDrSzxLGlqtOPhOU+hqIJsYb0Ey
Xtj5omdFyC3R+KF2AA2PQWVdia3lFq5UKQYhSRcLvpo2ouvnXK0y6ALU40iQiP51
NXoOFAxpTJZEsfLnnKFvX4M2e4y/8FVSijUr56r8Be7qfYGy9VDQV6SA7K+Eh++j
47HMFdvaUwPb9T0qJkNagQ63a+m+31MCWtZfVKm0gCXcBTUdRnL2pksH31MvcwlA
CC3fvoy6ll3Y5zZ44kGkNuhfRKbRqzDphEOwkRBTpe1EveVSgOVeNN/ranKlSPs=
=tHon
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----



More information about the MediaWiki-l mailing list