On Sun, Jun 5, 2011 at 11:14 PM, Theo10011 <de10011(a)gmail.com> wrote:
[..snip..]
You once requested 3 rights from stewards in one week
along with removal of
HPN, it's not common to get so many requests that often from an almost
inactive wikis. I have tried to point you to this mailing list and inform
you about HPN's work on several occasions. If you would have asked me before
the stewards, I would have pointed you to a written policy where by stewards
don't remove crats from other wikis by other's request simply for being
inactive. As for the comment, "which right do you want now", that's not an
uncommon way for people to joke about on IRC.
[..snip..]
On Sun, Jun 5, 2011 at 10:35 PM, Vibhi Jain
<vibhijain(a)yahoo.in> wrote:
>
[..snip..]
And now the removal, I don't think that this
right is not given to me, for
your information, I have also made a admin policy
for sa wiki. Its not that
I did it to take a revenge or anything. HPN has been inactive from 2007 on
sa wiki and made Mike a crat without community consensus. I also had a fight
with him regarding his removal (sorry if he felt angry with me). And who say
that I have placed a bid alone, just see the local team, you will also find
Mayur there.
[..snip..]
Thanks to Salman for putting some sanity into all this. Since this is being
discussed on the public list, I believe some clarifications are due.
I've had Mr. Vibhi Jain bombarding me with messages on Facebook and Google
Talk, seeking my 'retirement' as a sysop from Sanskrit Wikipedia. So much so
that it has been nothing short of a nuisance for me during work hours for
last couple of weeks. However, unlike our little enthusiastic friend seems
to suggest on this email about him having a fight (goodness gracious!),
there was no _fight_ involved. While I appreciate his enthusiasm, the
approach has been a no-go.
Mr. Vibhi Jain got in touch with me asking "whether I will be active on
Sanskrit Wikipedia or not". If not, he says *he has* drafted a policy which
allows to de-flag a sysop on Sanskrit Wikipedia. On couple of occasions when
he messaged me on Facebook and Google Chat, I tried telling him that
"focusing on improving the projects should be the goal" rather than kicking
people out. I also tried explaining him how "Wikipedians do go inactive at
times on some of the projects and that wouldn't mean they would never
contribute back to the projects". The conversation just ended with his
statements like (in his own words) "the policy will be soon ready. then
please do not say to me that i didn't told u".
Personally, I wouldn't be bothered if my id is deflagged or not. I would
just be helping out in any ways I can, either way.
I would just ignore some of these, pat on his back for the rest of the good
work he's been doing and move on. Having said that, I would definitely wish
that there would be more sanity injected into all this though, and guiding
new contributors in the right direction like Salman has done would always
help.
--
Hari Prasad Nadig
http://hpnadig.net |
http://twitter.com/hpnadig
http://flickr.com/hpnadig