Hi Srikanth R,
Please allow me to share my view.
On Sat, Dec 10, 2011 at 11:39 PM, Srikanth Ramakrishnan <
parakara.ghoda(a)gmail.com> wrote:
Hisham, I don't understand why the Executive
Committee offer to be
informed 48 HOURS in advance of the community. Isn't Wikipedia a
community based system? If the chapter or trust is everything then
what is the community sitting here to do? I know I sound rude, but I
fail to understand why some people get prior preference. Especially
after I spend an entire day talking to newcomers telling them that
everyone in Wiki is equal.
I am some times puzzled by assumption that people have about Wikipedia
policies for individuals related to editing a wiki page online apply
equally to real world Wikimedia organisations with accountabilties to
various stakeholders including Government. I am also concerned about the
assumed separation between community and chapter based on some recent mails
to the India list.
Let me elaborate my thoughts on this.
Chapter members including EC members are part of community and serve
Community and the movement. It is just the level and structure of
engagement of a person that determines whether he/she is part of Chapter.
If a person reads Wikipedia, he/she is member of community. If a person
contributes to Wikipedia, he/she is part of smaller subset of
communitycalled editors. If a person would like to promote Wikipedia
in real world,
he could do as an individual or become a member of chapter, leverage the
benefits of the legal entity called "Wikimedia chapter", get affiliated
with SIGs and contribute.
Chapter IRC is open for everyone. Even membership is open for every Indian
aged above 18. So I would request everyone to treat Chapter as a subset of
community with more focus on growing the movement in real world.
Coming to your specific question about the plan for sharing public
communications in advance, here is my view. As I understand, Trust is an
independent legal entity contributing to Wikimedia movement in India. So
the coordination calls are a mechanism to share plans and issues so that
the overall effectiveness can be improved. Advance notice for any public
communication was agreed so that each entity could provide the other
feedback if any, if such communication were to attribute some things to the
other or lead to confusion in the stakeholders. It is mutual. I am sorry
the minutes did not reflect the same, though it was discussed and agreed.
Hope the above helps. I request Hisham to share his view as well.
Cheers
Arjuna Rao Chavala
President, Wikimedia India
On 06/12/2011, Hisham <hisham(a)wikimedia.org> wrote:
Dear All
As you might be aware, we've been have a monthly call between the India
Chapter and India Programs team. Since we last updated you, we have had
2
calls and also a face-to-face meeting after
WikiConference. Here's an
update on these meetings.
I must beforehand apologize for being so late on updating you on these
calls
/ meetings. Shall endeavor to be more on
schedule going forward.
Do share your feedback and comments. Do let us know if there are any
clarifications we can provide.
Thursday November 9th (Voice Conference) [Arjun, Arun, Naveen, Sudhanwa,
Tinu, Asaf & Hisham]
India Programs Update
India Trust has been set up and a formal announcement will be made
shortly
on this matter.
India Education Program has encountered significant problems with regard
to
copy-pasted material. While efforts have been
made (including asking
for
help from Online Ambassadors), in-class sessions from Campus Ambassadors
(in
almost every single class of the program), asking
for intervention from
faculty, asking students only to work on sandboxes, etc., the situation
remained particularly serious at College of Engineering, Pune. As a
result,
the program was suspended at this college. It
currently runs at 1 class
at
Symbiosis School of Economics (while the other
classes there have
concluded
their assignments) and at 1 class at SNDT
Women's University.
Specifically, the lessons learnt on the pilot were discussed. These
included scale, choice of faculty, choice of classes, inadequate
engagement
and communication with en-wp community,
modifications to Campus
Ambassador
training going forward, modifications to student
training going forward,
etc. It was pointed out that a comprehensive and honest learnings
exercise
would be undertaken.
Recruitment of additional team members (for Communications and for Team
Support) have been delayed because the right candidate was not
available.
The initial work on the Indic Languages initiatives would start off with
preliminary discussions and data analysis of the various language
projects.
This will help to build a picture with both
experience and data of the
current state, challenges, opportunities and potential of the various
projects. Eventually, the objective will be to identify potential
pilots
and language communities that might be interested in these pilots.
Chapter Update
Arjun said that as Wikipedia is always evolving with contributions of
community, any project needs to be carefully planned and executed to
minimize the load on community. We had some experiences with Google
Translate project, which received adverse reaction from wikipedian
community. Even if Foundation undertakes an initiative, there is a
possibility of similar adverse response. He hoped that we can use this
experience to improve future project planning.
Sunday November 20th (Face to Face Meeting) [Arjun, Arun, Naveen,
Sudhanwa,
Tinu, Barry & Hisham]
India Programs Update
Point of View was shared about the nature of communication and
co-operation
between the Chapter and India Programs. It was
pointed out that all the
activities of India Programs have been in line with the publicly
available
The
monthly co-ordination calls that the Chapter EC
had initaited and that
are
now being regularly undertaken is useful and must
be continued. Chapter
EC
requested prior information on activities and it
was suggested by India
Programs (and agreed by Chapter EC) that all important announcements
would
be sent to the Chapter EC 48 hours before being
shared publicly.
The nature of the work that was happening on Indic Languages initiatives
was
shared (including the kinds of discussions and
how these discussions
were
being conducted) and that Shiju will shortly start sharing the updates
of
language discussions with the community.
The learnings process of the India Education Program was shared -
including
the fact that data gathering was going to be
commenced and that the
learnings would inform the next steps of the project. Nitika will
shortly
update the community about how these learnings
were going to be
gathered.
It was reiterated that the plans going forward would be finalized only
after
a thorough review of the program was conducted.
It was proposed to identify potential areas where the Chapter EC and
India
Programs would work collaboratively.
Chapter Update
Arjun said that it is essential to have clarity on the focus areas of
WMF
and identify projects where WMF and WMIN could work together. Arun
suggested
the need for a governance framework for the
various activities in India.
Arjun summarized the focus of Wikimedia India on Wiki academies and
Strengthening City/Language SIGs. Preliminary discussions around
Regional
Conferences, GLAM, Wiki loves monuments and Knowledge Kiosks are in
progress.
He explained how Knowledge Kiosks pilot, where visitors to public
libraries
can access Wikipedia through tablet computers in
the language of their
choice can be a great help for reaching out to the population, who can't
afford computers and Internet. He suggested that it can be a good
collaborative project and requested India programs support. India
programs
could take care of program management and dealing
with Library
organizations
and vendors. Chapter would help in training
library personnel and users
in
the various pilot locations. Hisham suggested
inviting fellowships for
such
a project. Arjun opined that organizational
help is really needed to
do
such projects. It is agreed to have further discussions on this topic
after
sharing additional information.
Wednesday November 23rd (Voice Conference) [Arjun, Arun, Naveen,
Sudhanwa &
Hisham]
India Programs Update
Ambiguity around the two entities "India Programs" and "India Trust"
were
clarified. India Programs is the team of consultants (currently,
Hisham,
Shiju & Nitika) who are working as consultants to WMF. Once the funding
for
the Wikimedia India Program Trust is sorted out
(after the appropriate
funding has the necessary approvals), these consultants will transition
to
the Trust. Until then, the Trust is an
organisation that has been
registered by has no funds available and therefore will not undertake
any
activities
An update was shared the the Trust was going to be filing for the
necessary
taxation related applications (Sections 12A and
80G) as well as FCRA
Prior-Permission in the next few days. An update will be shared after
these
have been done.
A discussion was made on the Chapter EC proposal for Chapter & India
Programs to work together on the Knowledge Kiosks initiative of the
Chapter.
India Programs indicated their preference not to
work on projects that
require such intensive effort in infrastructure building (both hardware
and
connectivity.) It was also recommended that the
Chapter carefully
consider
their involvement in such initiatives especially
given the kind of
effort
that will be required in stuff like procurement.
It was proposed that the Chapter EC and India Programs work
collaboratively
on at least 2 broad areas: supporting community
outreach & community
building (especially volunteer mobilization) as well PR & social media
with
Chapter EC. Both areas are aspects where India
Programs can bring
capability to the table and are areas of interest to members of the
Chapter
EC.
An update was shared on the meeting with the Ministry of HRD regarding
potential collaboration with Aakash tablet. The meeting was extremely
positive and holds potential. Hisham will be sharing an update to the
community on the next steps on this after some additional discussions.
It was proposed that a discussion commence that will collaboratively
arrive
at a draft document that provide clarity to how
Chapter EC and the India
Trust can work together. This will be in the nature of definition of
roles.
Chapter Update
Arjun said that with the kind of resources that the India Programs Trust
will have access, it can take up challenging projects like Knowledge
Kiosks
as it can certainly outsource stuff that can not
done by Trust. It is
agreed
to continue the discussion on this topic.
Best
hisham
--
Sent from my mobile device
Regards,
Srikanth Ramakrishnan.
Wikipedia Coimbatore Meetup on December 10th.
http://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Meetup/Coimbatore
_______________________________________________
Wikimediaindia-l mailing list
Wikimediaindia-l(a)lists.wikimedia.org
To unsubscribe from the list / change mailing preferences visit
https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikimediaindia-l