Does anyone on this list use on their own wiki one of the extensions in https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Category:Rating_extensions? If yes it would be useful to update their pages, to clarify * what releases work with what versions of MediaWiki, * what are the main traits/features you chose one or the other for.
For instance... * ReaderFeedback is a very old and stable extension; its page had not been updated in years but I tested and found out it still works in 1.19 (LTS). * CommunityVoice was very similar, had no version info but is found in the wild on a couple recent installs. * VoteNY has been abandoned for a long time, has seen some recent work but has no recent release info. * Of the others I know little or nothing. So the confusion is great.*
Nemo
(*) For AFTv4 vs. AFTv5, even inextricable. https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Article_feedback/Version_5/Report The other cases are hopefully simpler to test and describe.