On 24 July 2014 18:57, David Gerard dgerard@gmail.com wrote:
You're on moderation because you have (a) moderated your posting behaviour here, where you are on moderation (b) continued to post in this manner elsewhere, where you are not on moderation.
I have no idea what you are referring to. Since your action against me on this list, nobody has complained about my posts to other lists. I refute that I have "continued to post in this manner elsewhere" particularly as you have never pointed to any email of mine, but have preferred to make dark public implications of me being a bad person, without providing evidence of the bad things I have done.
This strongly suggests that moderation is the only thing keeping your posting behaviour acceptable.
Remember that the actual point is to make the list not toxic. So far, it appears moderation is doing that job.
This is based on no evidence. This would be a rationale for executing prisoners, as it is demonstrated to stop them from committing future imagined crimes.
I have noted that I am not personally inclined to remove the moderation, but that if any other moderator did I wouldn't object. So far none have done so, and instead have concurred with the above analysis.
Yes I understand something of your viewpoint, based on your recent post about me on Wikimedia-l saying "You're not on en:wp, so are not part of the "us" in question".http://lists.wikimedia.org/pipermail/wikimedia-l/2014-July/073239.html A bit surprising considering I have a GA review on the go.
Your analysis is not based on any evidence of things that I have written here that would be against policy.
Nobody has a right to post to this list. But so far every post you've made while on moderation has gone through.
On most Wikimedia projects, this would be a reason to re-examine sanctions. Wikipedia has the "standard offer" and a presumption of reform; it would be nice to see this positive way of thinking apply here, rather than repeated enforcement of stereotypes.
Fae -- faewik@gmail.com https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/User:Fae