2007/9/20, J.L.W.S. The Special One
<hildanknight(a)gmail.com>om>:
So, Andre, in your opinion, the question should
be: "Where do we draw the
line?"
That's why we need notability criteria that are objective, not subjective.
Yes, but the big problem, as I wrote, is that it's hard or impossible
to find objective criteria so that you don't have A and B, such that A
would be 'notable enough', B not 'notable enough', and at the same
time subjectively one would consider B to be 'higher' in notability
than A.
The problem is that a tiny number of editors think that THEY are the
sole arbiters of notability. The fact is that many concept are
notable to minority groups, and only the view of their group counts.
Abolish notability and you have no problem.
Regards,
Ian Tresman