From: Antid Oto <aorta(a)home.nl>
Date: 15 augustus 2007 17:33:45 CEST
To: Discussielijst over D66 <D66(a)nic.surfnet.nl>
Subject: See Who's Editing Wikipedia - Diebold, the CIA, a Campaign
REPLY TO: D66(a)nic.surfnet.nl
http://www.wired.com/politics/onlinerights/news/2007/08/wiki_tracker
On November 17th, 2005, an anonymous Wikipedia user deleted 15
paragraphs from an article on e-voting machine-vendor Diebold,
excising
an entire section critical of the company's machines. While anonymous,
such changes typically leave behind digital fingerprints offering
hints
about the contributor, such as the location of the computer used to
make
the edits.
In this case, the changes came from an IP address reserved for the
corporate offices of Diebold itself. And it is far from an isolated
case. A new data-mining service launched Monday traces millions of
Wikipedia entries to their corporate sources, and for the first time
puts comprehensive data behind longstanding suspicions of
manipulation,
which until now have surfaced only piecemeal in investigations of
specific allegations.
Wikipedia Scanner -- the brainchild of Cal Tech computation and
neural-systems graduate student Virgil Griffith -- offers users a
searchable database that ties millions of anonymous Wikipedia edits to
organizations where those edits apparently originated, by
cross-referencing the edits with data on who owns the associated block
of internet IP addresses.
Inspired by news last year that Congress members' offices had been
editing their own entries, Griffith says he got curious, and wanted to
know whether big companies and other organizations were doing
things in
a similarly self-interested vein.
"Everything's better if you do it on a huge scale, and automate
it," he
says with a grin.
This database is possible thanks to a combination of Wikipedia
policies
and (mostly) publicly available information.
The online encyclopedia allows anyone to make edits, but keeps
detailed
logs of all these changes. Users who are logged in are tracked only by
their user name, but anonymous changes leave a public record of
their IP
address.
The organization also allows downloads of the complete Wikipedia,
including records of all these changes.
Griffith thus downloaded the entire encyclopedia, isolating the
XML-based records of anonymous changes and IP addresses. He then
correlated those IP addresses with public net-address lookup services
such as ARIN, as well as private domain-name data provided by
IP2Location.com.
The result: A database of 34.4 million edits, performed by 2.6 million
organizations or individuals ranging from the CIA to Microsoft to
Congressional offices, now linked to the edits they or someone at
their
organization's net address has made.
Some of this appears to be transparently self-interested, either
adding
positive, press release-like material to entries, or deleting whole
swaths of critical material.
Voting-machine company Diebold provides a good example of the latter,
with someone at the company's IP address apparently deleting long
paragraphs detailing the security industry's concerns over the
integrity
of their voting machines, and information about the company's CEO's
fund-raising for President Bush.
The text, deleted in November 2005, was quickly restored by another
Wikipedia contributor, who advised the anonymous editor, "Please stop
removing content from Wikipedia. It is considered vandalism."
A Diebold Election Systems spokesman said he'd look into the matter
but
could not comment by press time.
Wal-Mart has a series of relatively small changes in 2005 that that
burnish the company's image on its own entry while often leaving
criticism in, changing a line that its wages are less than other
retail
stores to a note that it pays nearly double the minimum wage, for
example. Another leaves activist criticism on community impact intact,
while citing a "definitive" study showing Wal-Mart raised the total
number of jobs in a community.
As has been previously reported, politician's offices are heavy
users of
the system. Former Montana Sen. Conrad Burns' office, for example,
apparently changed one critical paragraph headed "A controversial
voice"
to "A voice for farmers," with predictably image-friendly content
following it.
Perhaps interestingly, many of the most apparently self-interested
changes come from before 2006, when news of the Congressional offices'
edits reached the headlines. This may indicate a growing
sophistication
with the workings of Wikipedia over time, or even the rise of
corporate
Wikipedia policies.
Wikipedia founder Jimmy Wales told Wired News he was aware of the new
service, but needed time to experiment with it before commenting.
The vast majority of changes are fairly innocuous, however.
Employees at
the CIA's net address, for example, have been busy -- but with little
that would indicate their place of apparent employment, or a
particular
bias.
One entry on "Black September in Jordan" contains wholesale additions,
with specific details that read like a popular history book or an
eyewitness' memoir.
Many more are simple copy edits, or additions to local town entries or
school histories. One CIA entry deals with the details of lyrics
sung in
a Buffy the Vampire Slayer episode.
Griffith says he launched the project hoping to find scandals,
particularly at obvious targets such as companies like Halliburton.
But
there's a more practical goal, too: By exposing the anonymous edits
that
companies such as drugs and big pharmaceutical companies make in
entries
that affect their businesses, it could help experts check up on the
changes and make sure they're accurate, he says.
For now, he has just scratched the surface of the database of millions
of entries. But he's putting it online so others can look too.
The nonprofit Wikimedia Foundation, which runs Wikipedia, did not
respond to e-mail and telephone inquiries Monday.
**********
Dit bericht is verzonden via de informele D66 discussielijst
(D66(a)nic.surfnet.nl).
Aanmelden: stuur een email naar LISTSERV(a)nic.surfnet.nl met in het
tekstveld alleen: SUBSCRIBE D66 uwvoornaam uwachternaam
Afmelden: stuur een email naar LISTSERV(a)nic.surfnet.nl met in het
tekstveld alleen: SIGNOFF D66
Het on-line archief is te vinden op:
http://listserv.surfnet.nl/
archives/d66.html
**********