On Wed, 2002-10-30 at 18:42, elian wrote: <snip> You failed to include my vote against voting. You may consider that a "blank", if you wish.
Possible proceedings:
- Doing nothing and leave things as they are
- put a redirection in place
- put a portal in place
- since the majority seems to favor the portal solution, further
discussion could be directed towards developping a portal solution which is acceptable for its opponents, too. For doing this it would be necessary to know what the portal should include to be acceptable.. 5) Any other ideas???
Hmm...this doesn't seem like a survey intended for your personal use. This seems like an attempt to force decisions based on a push poll.
There has been more than enough discussion on what the opponents of the portal "solution" consider the problems. It should not be necessary to reiterate them.
Numerous other ideas have been presented.
It would be best if you somewhere stated explicitly in one place how you perceive the problem and what your proposed solution is. For example, see [[Wikipedia talk:Bots]].
The Cunctator cunctator@kband.com writes:
You failed to include my vote against voting. You may consider that a "blank", if you wish.
I honestly thought about doing this but wasn't sure which action you would regard as the worse affront ;-)
Hmm...this doesn't seem like a survey intended for your personal use. This seems like an attempt to force decisions based on a push poll.
Since only one person opted for no changes, people seem to want a decision. There is no reason for doing nothing now.
Numerous other ideas have been presented.
It would help if you would be a little bit more specific and constructive.
It would be best if you somewhere stated explicitly in one place how you perceive the problem and what your proposed solution is. For example, see [[Wikipedia talk:Bots]].
Why don't you start with this? Since you didn't seem to be interested at all in developping a compromise I came to regard discussion with you as a waste of energy. Maybe you can convince me of the contrary?
greetings, elian
wikipedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org