Matt (Montréalais) a ecrivé:
- Je me demande s'il existe une politique sur le Wiki français par rapport - aux orthographes régionales de même qu'existe sur le Wiki anglais.
If this means that French and English wikipedias should have a similar naming convention for geographic terms, then I strongly agree.
I didn't understand the "Village gai" stuff. It sounds like a discussion about the [[gay village]] article, which in turn sounds like the idea of calling parts of various cities "Chinatown". As in, "I went to Chinatown last night and ate eggrolls at a Chinese restaurant."
I understand the slang use of "gay" as: * referring to homosexuals & homosexuality * becoming increasingly a mainstream term (as in "gay rights")
I apologize for my inability to read French accurately. Il y a 25 ans que je l'ai etudié.
Ed Poor, aka [[Edmond Le Pauvre]]
Poor, Edmund W wrote:
Matt (Montréalais) a ecrivé:
- Je me demande s'il existe une politique sur le Wiki français par rapport
- aux orthographes régionales de même qu'existe sur le Wiki anglais.
If this means that French and English wikipedias should have a similar naming convention for geographic terms, then I strongly agree.
I didn't understand the "Village gai" stuff. It sounds like a discussion about the [[gay village]] article, which in turn sounds like the idea of calling parts of various cities "Chinatown". As in, "I went to Chinatown last night and ate eggrolls at a Chinese restaurant."
The French debate is not about gay rights. It is instead a parallel to the American/British or labor/labour issue. In France "gay" is the preferred usage; in Québec "gai" is the preferred usage. "Village gai" is a Montreal usage that is an accepted geographical name for the area. That should override the spelling of "gai/gay" as applied to more generic gay villages anywhere in the world. The person from France was wanting to insist that the anglicised spelling "gay" should apply in all circumstances.
I hope that that clarifies what the argument was about.
Eclecticology
--- "Poor, Edmund W" Edmund.W.Poor@abc.com wrote:
Matt (Montr�alais) a ecriv�:
- Je me demande s'il existe une politique sur le
Wiki fran�ais par rapport
- aux orthographes r�gionales de m�me qu'existe sur
le Wiki anglais.
If this means that French and English wikipedias should have a similar naming convention for geographic terms, then I strongly agree.
No, it is not what was meant in fact.
It is quite likely we won't have exactly the same naming conventions for geographic terms than the english. What makes you believe we name things and cities the same way as you do ;-) and what makes you believe we would use your conventions ;-)))
What Matt referred to is the way all french speaking don't use the same orthographic rules, and sometimes not the same words at all for a concept. Just like your fertilisation/fertilization stuff (sorry Mav, I again forgot which from the s and the z was the english or american, my memory is a sieve) or Lorry/truck or corn/maize.
For example Matt wanted to use the word gai. For French, it means happy. For Canadians homosexual. We rather know gay to say homosexual. So, one french said the proper orthographic rule (gai) was not respected, and the canadian word had to be replaced by the french one (gay). (academic weight)
Pretty simple no ?
Just need a reminder that francophone is different from french, and that the fr in front of the web adress is for francophone.
I didn't understand the "Village gai" stuff. It sounds like a discussion about the [[gay village]] article, which in turn sounds like the idea of calling parts of various cities "Chinatown". As in, "I went to Chinatown last night and ate eggrolls at a Chinese restaurant."
I understand the slang use of "gay" as:
- referring to homosexuals & homosexuality
- becoming increasingly a mainstream term (as in
"gay rights")
I apologize for my inability to read French accurately. Il y a 25 ans que je l'ai etudi�.
Ed, voici pour vous l'occasion r�v�e de faire des progr�s. Si ce n'est pour lire, sinon pour �crire.
Ed Poor, aka [[Edmond Le Pauvre]]
Certaines formations priv�es vous feraient payer une fortune pour une telle exp�rience.
__________________________________________________ Do you Yahoo!? Yahoo! Mail Plus � Powerful. Affordable. Sign up now. http://mailplus.yahoo.com
wikipedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org