I have to say that Gareth and I have had our differences in the past but I am with him 100% on this; historical revisionism in any shape or form is not to be countenanced. Ever.

Reportage is not approval. If some group of folks makes enough noise to get attention, and has published a book with silly ideas, it is every bit as much of a moral obligation for us to honestly report that fact as it is for us to to express disapproval (or to report that most people disapprove).