The page for Little Earthquakes, a Tori Amos album, includes an extract from one of the album's songs. This seems a bit dubious, copyright-wise! I've removed the link for now, to be safe. Does anyone know if the extract is legally OK for inclusion in Wikipedia? Check the history of Tori Amos/Little Earthquakes to see the page with the link (damn subpages).
Adam Williamson wrote:
The page for Little Earthquakes, a Tori Amos album, includes an extract from one of the album's songs. This seems a bit dubious, copyright-wise! I've removed the link for now, to be safe. Does anyone know if the extract is legally OK for inclusion in Wikipedia? Check the history of Tori Amos/Little Earthquakes to see the page with the link (damn subpages).
There was some talk about this a few weeks ago, somthing about the articel of Simon and Garfunkel (there is also audio there). The English Wikipedia calls it "fair use" and allow it. The Dutch Wikipedia calls it a copyright violation and does not allow it. Do not know of the others. -- giskart
On Mon, 2002-09-09 at 23:32, Giskart wrote:
Adam Williamson wrote:
The page for Little Earthquakes, a Tori Amos album, includes an extract from one of the album's songs. This seems a bit dubious, copyright-wise! I've removed the link for now, to be safe. Does anyone know if the extract is legally OK for inclusion in Wikipedia? Check the history of Tori Amos/Little Earthquakes to see the page with the link (damn subpages).
There was some talk about this a few weeks ago, somthing about the articel of Simon and Garfunkel (there is also audio there). The English Wikipedia calls it "fair use" and allow it. The Dutch Wikipedia calls it a copyright violation and does not allow it. Do not know of the others. -- giskart
Ah, that's a point. Forgot about the 5% of copyright material rule. HOWEVER, I believe in music isn't the track as well as the entire recording under copyright? i.e., you could only take 5% of a track? Anyone know?
At 2002-09-10 00:32 +0200, Giskart wrote:
Adam Williamson wrote:
The page for Little Earthquakes, a Tori Amos album, includes an extract from one of the album's songs. This seems a bit dubious, copyright-wise! I've removed the link for now, to be safe. Does anyone know if the extract is legally OK for inclusion in Wikipedia? Check the history of Tori Amos/Little Earthquakes to see the page with the link (damn subpages).
There was some talk about this a few weeks ago, somthing about the articel of Simon and Garfunkel (there is also audio there). The English Wikipedia calls it "fair use" and allow it. The Dutch Wikipedia calls it a copyright violation and does not allow it. Do not know of the others. -- giskart
Correction: We didn't arrive at a consensus on the Dutch Wikipedia. I think that a small fragment should be fair-use. Also under Dutch law (which is basically the same as current USA/international law as I explained here earlier). On the Dutch Wikipedia we decided to 'disallow' such audio fragments for now because there was little need for it yet and we didn't want to pursue the matter further at this stage.
Greetings, Jaap
wikipedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org