Scríobh Jens Ropers:
Quite true, however for most (if not all) languages, there is a flag that is commonly understood to symbolize the language as well (depending on context). No other symbols exist that so clearly and graphically identify the respective languages. And I thing it having the instant visual indentification that you can get with images is worthwhile. That said, someone has removed the flags now (without explanatory comment) and I'm taking my time about reverting, because I believe community consensus will decide this one.
I agree that the flags look pretty, but there are just too many languages and countries where they don't sync. What flag do you put to Afrikaans, Tibetan, Breton, or Navajo? Either you end up repeating flags, or some entries don't have one at all, which looks very ugly.
Nice idea, and it looks visually agreeable, but it's just not practical.
Regards, - Craig Franklin
------------------- Craig Franklin PO Box 764 Ashgrove, Q, 4060 Australia http://www.halo-17.net - Australia's Favourite Source of Indie Music, Art, and Culture.
Craig Franklin wrote:
Scríobh Jens Ropers:
Quite true, however for most (if not all) languages, there is a flag that is commonly understood to symbolize the language as well (depending on context). No other symbols exist that so clearly and graphically identify the respective languages. And I thing it having the instant visual indentification that you can get with images is worthwhile. That said, someone has removed the flags now (without explanatory comment) and I'm taking my time about reverting, because I believe community consensus will decide this one.
I agree that the flags look pretty, but there are just too many languages and countries where they don't sync. What flag do you put to Afrikaans, Tibetan, Breton, or Navajo? Either you end up repeating flags, or some entries don't have one at all, which looks very ugly.
Nice idea, and it looks visually agreeable, but it's just not practical.
Although I don't support the idea of relating a language to a flag it's not because these flags don't exist.
See http://www.crwflags.com/fotw/flags/fr-bz.html and http://www.crwflags.com/fotw/flags/us-navjo.html
Ec
wikipedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org