You know, the more I hear about this idea, the more I enjoy it. Personally, I don't really see the point of the categories system - you get everything mixed together with no context that way, and I don't see any way it can be made to work so that you can do a search for multiple keywords, like "Jewish", "Authors", "Died 1945", "Females". Heck, I imagine that if you tried to put a category of any of those together, some well-meaning person would probably delete them anyway, claiming they weren't specific enough.
The only thing is that it should be kept as simple as possible, some of the proposals I see are too complicated for "ordinary" users to understand. We shouldn't require that a user be familiar with complex metadata tagging schemes just to write articles - even if those schemes are the widely adopted standards on the Internet at large.
Regards, - Craig Franklin
------------------- Craig Franklin PO Box 764 Ashgrove, Q, 4060 Australia http://www.halo-17.net - Australia's Favourite Source of Indie Music, Art, and Culture.
On Sun, 20 Mar 2005 12:05:30 +1000, Craig Franklin craig@halo-17.net wrote:
The only thing is that it should be kept as simple as possible, some of the proposals I see are too complicated for "ordinary" users to understand. We shouldn't require that a user be familiar with complex metadata tagging schemes just to write articles - even if those schemes are the widely adopted standards on the Internet at large.
Thats why it's a wiki... "ordinary" user writes the page.. Omits the metadata, because they don't understand it, aren't aware of it, or just don't care.
Someone else notices the missing metadata and adds it, ... and since they apparently care about metadata they probably known enough to do it right, even if the system turns out to be fairly complicated.
The metadata for an article will likely change very slowly, if at all, so keeping the metadata accurate should be a non-issue.
Craig Franklin wrote:
You know, the more I hear about this idea, the more I enjoy it. Personally, I don't really see the point of the categories system - you get everything mixed together with no context that way, and I don't see any way it can be made to work so that you can do a search for multiple keywords, like "Jewish", "Authors", "Died 1945", "Females". Heck, I imagine that if you tried to put a category of any of those together, some well-meaning person would probably delete them anyway, claiming they weren't specific enough.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Jews http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Writers http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:1945_deaths The only one missing is "females" :)
wikipedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org