I have been asked to look at a page where there has been an edit war for half a year as an 'impartial outsider'. Does anyone have experience with doing that? I have not started yet, but I fear that the outcome will be one of the following three:
* I consider myself too little known about the subject to say anything useful * I agree with one of the parties, and get shit on by the other parties * I agree with neither party, and get shit on by both.
Andre Engels schreef:
I have been asked to look at a page where there has been an edit war for half a year as an 'impartial outsider'. Does anyone have experience with doing that? I have not started yet, but I fear that the outcome will be one of the following three:
- I consider myself too little known about the subject to say anything
useful
- I agree with one of the parties, and get shit on by the other parties
- I agree with neither party, and get shit on by both.
Hoi, This is one of the dubious advantages of being a member of an arbitration committee. :) Thanks, GerardM
wikipedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org