Salut Ronline,
Nu stiu daca ai urmarit ultima discutie referitoare la wikipedia moldoveneasca, dar la un moment dat Mark Williamson mi-a trimis un mesaj injurios.
Acum, vor si altii sa il vada, in cont, ca sa se asigure ca intr-adevar el l-a trimis. Insa e vorba de un cont Yahoo, si deci daca dau acces la el si e sters mesajul nu mai am "dovada". :)
Am deci nevoie de un trustee, un user respectat pe wikipedia, care sa se uite primul si sa vada mesajul acolo. Apoi, poate sa se uite cine o vrea.
Ai putea, te rog, sa fii trustee in directia asta? Daca da, iti trimit parola, te uiti, si eventual faci o copie a mesajului.
Numai bine, Jacky (Dpotop)
ps: Cel care vrea sa se uite e Liviu Andronic. Tu stii cumva cine e?
--- "Wikipedia Romania (Ronline)" rowikipedia@gmail.com wrote:
Your Wikipedia may be larger than ours, but ours
is higher quality.
Maybe we should delete the Romanian Wikipedia
instead? As you can see,
it is clearly substandard -- the only Wikipedia of
its size with less
bytes per article is the Swedish Wikipedia. No
other Wikipedia is as
low, until you get down under 7000 articles.
Mark
I'm not particularly getting involved in this whole Moldovan argument again, but I think your point above is highly misleading. The Moldovan Wikipedia is not in any way of higher quality than the Romanian Wikipedia, because byte size doesn't reflect this, for two reasons:
- Nearly all articles on the Moldovan wiki have a
corresponding Romanian article of the same or greater length. This is because a significant number of them were transliterated from the Romanian Wikipedia. 2) The grammatical quality of the mo: articles is arguably lower. This is the more subtle aspect of quality, and also includes things like depth of coverage and systemic bias.
So, the Romanian Wikipedia is of a higher functionality than the mo.wiki, and its quality is also higher, because it basically contains all of the info that mo. contains, plus more.
In any case, the argument for closing the mo:wiki was that it is has poor quality articles and is a playground for trolling, not that it particularly has a low article or byte-size count.
On 24/06/06, Jacky PB dpotop1@yahoo.com wrote:
... it should be closed now
Amen ! (I cut the oppinion of Francis Tyers out of a
context that hides it).
If only it were possible to get a non-involved
party to look at this
for
5 minutes and decide one way or the other. It
would save everyone a
hell
of a lot of time. What we need is a knee jerk
binding judgement! (of
course this is said partly in jest, but we
really aren't going to get
anywhere by 'discussing' this).
Well, **you** of all are non-involved. And after
following this
discussion for a **long** time you ended with the
same conclusion:
Regardless of what the Moldovan language is or is
not, there are no native
contributors, and there is one single contributor
overall (who actually
cannot contribute because he is at level mo-2).
Isn't this enough?
Dpotop
Want to be your own boss? Learn how on Yahoo!
Small Business.
Wikipedia-l mailing list Wikipedia-l@Wikimedia.org
http://mail.wikipedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikipedia-l
-- Refije dirije lanmè yo paske nou posede pwòp bato. _______________________________________________ Wikipedia-l mailing list Wikipedia-l@Wikimedia.org
http://mail.wikipedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikipedia-l
Wikipedia-l mailing list Wikipedia-l@Wikimedia.org
http://mail.wikipedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikipedia-l
__________________________________________________ Do You Yahoo!? Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around http://mail.yahoo.com