Mark Williamson wrote:
This was
definitely POV vote stacking and was intellectually
dishonest yes. Biased, unwiki and loaded with personal attacks.
OK. Then you tell me, when I set up a poll, who am I supposed to tell?
Am I supposed to post to the village pump of every Wikipedia??
I would recommend that you think about who is likely to be interested,
and inform them. I would not complain at all if no one posted to the
Hungarian Wikipedia village pump.
And how is vote stacking loaded with personal attacks?
It assumes that Mandarin speakers are dishonest or politically
motivated, and not just a little bit, but to the extent that their voice
should be silenced. That's a personal attack.
I trust Cantonese speakers. I trust Mandarin speakers. Careful
thoughtful reasoned discussion will help us all come to a consensus
about this. Silencing people deliberately not informing them of a vote
that you know to be relevant to them does not help.
--Jimbo