On 16/02/2019 21:30, Paulo Santos Perneta wrote:
Dear Paulo,
OTRS can be used to verify and certify any kind of
private information,
not only identity of people. In Wikipedia we generally and usually send
people to OTRS when they want to prove such kind of thing as their
birthdate, without having to expose publicly their IDs. As far as I
know, that's how it works.
I confess that my knowlege of what is actually and routinely going on in
OTRS is based on indirect (and partial) observation (and I'd like to
know more about it) but I don't see how an example such as ours would
work. What and where would be the cited reference in the article in such
a change ?
the quality of
a source generally degrades with the number of times it is quoted and
recycled, so that secondary sources would be generally worst, and
tertiary sources, as paper encyclopedias and newspapers, would generally
be the worst possible ones.
Well I believe we disagree on the merits of primary and secondary
sources then. I believe that the virtue of secondary sources lies in its
analysis, which is supposed to be missing in the primary sources, not
its quotation.
--
***********************************************
Alexandre Hocquet
Université de Lorraine & Archives Henri Poincaré
Alexandre.Hocquet(a)univ-lorraine.fr
http://poincare.univ-lorraine.fr/fr/membre-titulaire/alexandre-hocquet
***********************************************