J.L.W.S. The Special One wrote:
Even if we don't draw an exact line, we can reduce
the range of values for
which a reasonable Wikipedian would draw it at.
"One-size-fits-all" notability criteria are impossible to set. We need
topic-specific notability guidelines that could determine notability, or
lack thereof, in at least 90% of cases (exceptions will always exist).
Moreover, notability criteria should not be systemically biased. For
example, the notability criteria for films states that a film which wins a
"major award" is notable. In a footnote, the Academy Awards and Cannes are
listed as examples of "major awards". However, what about Chinese films?
Shouldn't the Golden Horse Awards be considered "major"?
India is the
country which produces the most films, but very few of them
are known.
Ec