Oui ! The french wikipedia has become a hunt place for commas ! Even in articles less than 10 words long...
Ouhl�l�... Warning commas-hunters ! Anthere is back !!!
Ah, Tim ! Si tu n'existais pas, il faudrait t'inventer !
Tiens, d'ailleurs, faudra que tu nous explique comment on te reconnait, car franchement, connaitre ta cl�, �a ne m'avance pas du tout du tout du tout
Et tant que je ne comprend pas, Tim , c'est Tim, et Tim, c'est toi
Anthere, take a look at [[SHA-1]] and tell me how many commas are there? There is only one, and it is not needed, from a stylistic point of view. This article is a very good example : Some articles may not have commas, unless they are long and complete enough to be considerated as articles.
I never said the comma technic was the right one to count an article as a "good" article Your example is an extrem case. I see no pb with you adding a comma here.
But all the articles you did this morning, with commas in comments are much poorer than SHA-1, and imho hardly deserve the name of encyclopedic articles. Dictionary articles yes, but not encyclopedia articles.
This is a dictionary article, with commas in comment :
http://fr.wikipedia.org/w/wiki.phtml?title=Aiguchi&diff=0&oldid=3434...
That's why I have added commas to every article which doesn't have one... C'est aussi simple que �a.
Why not a mix between the comma method, and a
certain
number of words ? (at least people will know how
to
count ;-))
Greater-than-zero-size check is simple and efficient enough...
It is simple. But it is slightly ridiculous. Certainly not the best way to convince newcomers we are a great resource
By the way, I am happy that Tim took some time to improve some of Tim articles. Have you seen ?
http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banane
Athymik (athymik@ifrance.com) Cl� publique http://athymik.devveb.org/public_key.asc
Attention, cl� publique, nous avons affaire � un Tim certifi� !
Ant
__________________________________________________ Do you Yahoo!? Yahoo! Tax Center - forms, calculators, tips, more http://taxes.yahoo.com/