--- The Cunctator cunctator@kband.com wrote:
It would if the premises were correct. It is true that the point of an encyclopedia is to be authoritative. But it does not follow that encyclopedias do not list references. Most do, in fact. They may call it "further reading" or somesuch, but they're references.
Moreover, traditional encyclopedias assert authoritativeness by having known experts write the entries.
For example, Encyclopedia Britannica's entry on baseball includes the following "further reading" (written in paragraph form in EB):
- Lawrence Ritter and Donald Honig, The Image of Their Greatness:
An Illustrated History of Baseball from 1900 to the Present, updated ed. (1984);
- Lawrence S. Ritter (comp.), The Glory of Their Times: The Story
of the Early Days of Baseball Told by the Men Who Played It, new ed. (1984).
- Robert Peterson, Only the Ball Was White (1970, reprinted 1984).
- David Quentin Voigt, Baseball, an Illustrated History (1987)
- The Official Baseball Guide, The Sporting News
- Official Baseball Register, The Sporting News
- Joseph L. Reichler (ed.), The Baseball Encyclopedia, 7th rev.
ed. (1988).
- Joe Brinkman and Charlie Euchner, The Umpire's Handbook, rev. ed.
(1987).
- Bill James and John Dewan, Bill James Presents the Great American
Baseball Stat Book, ed. by Geoff Beckman et al. (1987)
and is written by Jerome Holtzman, "Baseball columnist, Chicago Tribune. Elected to the Writers' Wing, National Baseball Hall of Fame, 1990. Coauthor of Three and Two; editor of No Cheering in the Press Box; Fielder's Choice."
Since Wikipedia cannot assert authoritativeness based on the entries being written by experts (that's the Nupedia project, more or less), it can only do so through listing references.
References other than newspaper articles should generally be preferred, but they're better than nothing.
Ok, I hear you.
But then, do they need to be links? I think the reference should be listed as one might do in a research paper (do we have a reference style?), and include a link for convenience only.
===== Christopher Mahan chris_mahan@yahoo.com 818.943.1850 cell http://www.christophermahan.com/
__________________________________________________ Do you Yahoo!? Yahoo! Tax Center - File online, calculators, forms, and more http://tax.yahoo.com