Larry Sanger wrote:
FYI, I did ask the Catholic Encyclopedia web editor for permission when the same issue came up probably about a year ago. I didn't get a reply, if I recall correctly. It's worth trying again, but I doubt they have a nice view the prospect of the encyclopedia's content being included in Wikipedia.
If we feel we don't have one, it would be good to get a definitive view on such issues, when they arise, from a lawyer, and then just proceed regardless of what New Advent says (or fail to say).
Larry
Stone-walling can be a very effective tactic when someone's copyright claim is tenuous at best. The unfortunate problem with prophylactic legal opinions is that they are necessarily provided in the absence of actual opposition.
Eclecticology