michael west wrote:
On 10/08/07, Yury Tarasievich yury.tarasievich@gmail.com wrote:
Okay, let's simplify the issue -- let's talk about whether academic
views, which weren't actually challenged on their factual or interpretational basis, may be blocked from inclusion on basis of their unfamiliarity to some of the editors?
No never, Editors who are unfamiliar with a topic should never have any input to say this is good this is bad, I will search google etc....
That's a harsh criterion. Who decides whether someone is unfamiliar with the subjec.
Ec