I'm not trying to restart the debate - it went on quite long enough as it was! But what was the consensus on naming wikipedia entries for cities? Did it come out to [[city, country]] or was that shouted down by the masses? The reason I ask is because I'm looking at a couple of entries that might be moved and I don't know whether they should...
As far as I can judge it, the following rules seem to have gotten majorities:
* Normal rules on disambiguation apply: When there is no need to disambiguate (that is, if there is no other subject with the same name, nor likely to come into existence soon, or when the city is clearly the most important subject under its title), we use simply [[City]]. * When there is a need to disambiguate, [[City, Country]] is used, unless there is a special case or there is a need to disambiguate within a country. * Special case are at the moment the USA and Canada, using [[City, State]] and [[City, Province]], respectively.
What, as far as I can see, has NOT been decided on yet, is whether American and Canadian cities get their State/Province addition even in absence of any necessity for disambiguation.
Andre Engels