Daniel Mayer wrote:
OK, I'm a bit pissed. The first two voting "users" who I checked don't have /any/ Wikipedia contributions. They linked to their user pages on de.wiki so I checked their contribs;
http://de.wikipedia.org/w/wiki.phtml?title=Spezial:Contributions&target=... Only contrib /ever/ was to create a user page
http://de.wikipedia.org/w/wiki.phtml?title=Spezial:Contributions&target=... No contribs at all for this account
This is beyond the pale. I hereby call for a recount and a validation of every vote; in order to have a vote counted each and every person should have to declare which Wikipedia they are a contributor to and to provide a link to their Wikipedia user page.
I'm not willing to propose what the defintion of a "contributor" is at the moment, but certainly the two "users" above do not fit the bill.
Did you simply forget to put a smiley on that last suggestion?
Ec