2010/5/10 Marcus Buck <me(a)marcusbuck.org>rg>:
J Alexandr Ledbury-Romanov hett schreven:
I have a problem with basing it on IP addresses.
As a non Muslim in a Muslim
country, why should Wikimedia decide that *I* cannot see Muhammad pictures
but that it is perfectly OK to show it to a Muslim in Germany / France
wherever. I think the world has moved on a bit from the one country, one
religion / set of values / morals.
You are of course right. But what is the alternative? The only
alternative is not basing it on location so everybody sees the same.
That's like "one world, one set of values".
The alternative is to not censor, in any circumstance, to any kind of
audience whatsoever. I must confess I find this particular alternative
brilliant.
It is imperfect, as any other form of freedom of thought and
expression. But other options are more imperfect, not less, in my
opinion.
I think some projects (like the English Wikipedia) already reached
consensus on this issue.
--
Elias Gabriel Amaral da Silva <tolkiendili(a)gmail.com>