2007/2/18, Artur Fijałkowski <wiki.warx(a)gmail.com>:
> > Well, I just got an explanation for that:
> > 1. Official foundation policy is that open proxies are blocked
>
> * Why for logged in users?
Because there was only one way of blocking when the policy was created.
2. Any change from that should work and have no negative consequences
> > 3. This change does not work because people in countries with these IP
> > still
> > cannot work on WikipediaNL
> > 4. This change has the negative side effect that people can create a
> > sockpuppet and use an open IP to edit from their sock puppet, which
> makes
> > sock puppets less easy to detect.
>
> * where is 'Assume good faith' ?
I don't think we have a rule 'assume good faith' on nl:. Apart from that, I
cannot answer questions about the opinions of people I don't agree with...
Do I agree with this? No. But I'm not a sysop, so my voice don't count. And
> > if I were a sysop, probably anything I do would be considered wheel
> > warring,
> > with me voluntarily giving up sysop powers being the most likely
> outcome.
>
>
> * Always thought that sysops are for helping Wikimedians not only banning
> :(
I guess that relationships are too much damaged on nl: to make that a valid
option. There's quite a few people who feel it's "us vs. them", with them
being the sysops. Or at least are of the opinion that the sysops have too
much power.
--
Andre Engels, andreengels(a)gmail.com
ICQ: 6260644 -- Skype: a_engels
