Hmmm... Now I see I sent this to wikipedia-l, not foundation-l. Those interested can read the discussion there. I'm getting as angry as Waerth, almost...
To put this thing to something that actually belongs on foundation-l: I would favor repealing the foundation policy that open proxies are blocked.
My reasons are: * Main reason for the policy is that there is no reason for editing Wikipedia from a proxy. I disagree, seeing already three; ** Editing on subjects where one could get problems for writing from a searching POV and/or NPOV ** People who always use a proxy for extra anonymity and have to switch it off to work on Wikipedia now ** Cases like Waerth who are automatically sent through an anonymous proxy by their provider * Large-scale vandalism using many proxies does occur, but is rare enough that blocking the proxies when they are being used for vandalism is no big issue.
On 2/18/07, Andre Engels andreengels@gmail.com wrote: [snip]
** Cases like Waerth who are automatically sent through an anonymous proxy by their provider
I'll gladly run a closed access proxy for any established wikimedians whom are interested.
I'll even make it available as a tor hidden service so even I don't learn your IP. If anyone is interested, just let me know off-list.
- Large-scale vandalism using many proxies does occur, but is rare enough
that blocking the proxies when they are being used for vandalism is no big issue.
Rare on which wikis? Without proxy blocking people do real damage with high speed automated attacks.
...
Waerth, for two hours this morning I spoke with you and with dutch people to try to sort it out, even try to solve the problem, you keep insulting people...
What's the point? I try to do what I can, peacefully, and you you insults everyone. You're angry? Fine, but this is more than useless as long as your insults are annoying people who would have helped you...
The funny thing is I'm pretty sure if you said "please" "I apologize" "I'm sorry" instead of "fuck" more people would have helped you.
wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org