Hi Nathan, what you're describing is an opt-out practice. I believe that the practice should be opt-in.
Take this with a grain of salt. I participate in some grantmaking and administrative groups and I err on the side of privacy, but I'm fairly confident that the Privacy Policy applies in this case and that the practice should be opt-in for republication, even if not explicitly required by policy, because it's the more conservative and more courteous approach. In general this community is conservative about privacy issues, although we are also interested in transparency, which makes for an interesting mix of priorities.
Pine
wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org