Дана Saturday 21 March 2009 01:52:06 Erik Moeller написа:
2009/3/20 Nikola Smolenski <smolensk(a)eunet.yu>yu>:
The fact
that they may or may not be logged in is completely
irrelevant if the terms and conditions clarify that their username has
nothing to do with the option of supplying an Original Author name as
But the terms and conditions do not clarify that, anywhere.
So let's step back for a second. There is a claim that the legal code
of CC-BY-SA cannot be reconciled with the notion of attributing via
URL-linkback only. Do you agree that this claim is false? If the claim
Of course it is false. CC-BY-SA can be reconciled with attributing by URL only
(or even with not attributing at all), however in our practice it isn't.
for a website under which authors contribute under
such a model. If it
is possible, then the final question is whether the current proposed
terms for the edit page satisfy those conditions. I contend that they
do, because they are sufficiently clear about the intended
consequences (we don't need to spell out in detail how the terms and
I read them, and I know I still expected that in print my name would be there
somewhere.