2009/3/3 Michael Snow <wikipedia(a)verizon.net>
But someone making a request is a sign that the
article really needs a
hard look, and quite possibly should be removed for not meeting our
standards. So the reversed presumption of "default to delete, unless
consensus to keep" is a good idea for living subjects. I would add that
when this is in question, arguments that make excuses for the current
state of the article are not valid reasons to keep it.
I am just clarifying - "default to delete unless consensus to keep"
would be
a change from current state, right?
I ask because I got a call the other day from someone asking to have the BLP
about her deleted. The article centred around a single incident in her
life. I handed it off to a longtime English Wikipedian (doesn't matter
who), who told me the subject was notable and therefore the article would be
kept.
That experience was consistent with my general understanding - that it has
been extremely difficult for even marginally notable people to get the BLP
about them deleted.
So -again, just to clarify- if Wikipedia adopted a practice of defaulting to
delete unless there's consensus to keep, that would be change from how BLPs
are handled today - yes?
_______________________________________________
foundation-l mailing list
foundation-l(a)lists.wikimedia.org
Unsubscribe:
https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/foundation-l
I am not sure how it is handled on en-wp. If it was on zh-wp and if it
is me whom you wrote I would do following: I would put the article to
vote for delete with a remark that the person requested for delete. I
would put a remark in village pump because this is a delete request that
is not under the usual procedure to get more attention and I would leave
a remark with link on the Skype chat room (this mainly because of the
chinese community heavily use Skype) I would also leave a remark on the
user talk page who had created or largely extended the article about the
delete request. So it is either a per default keep nor a per default
delete. I think it is a your attention please we need talk about this.
Ting