Aphaia wrote:
On 9/29/06, Erik Moeller <erik(a)wikimedia.org>
wrote:
On 9/28/06, Brion Vibber <brion(a)pobox.com>
wrote:
What doesn't work about it?
Let's start with the most obvious bit: WMF is an international
organization, and we want volunteers to contribute as many
translations as possible of key pages on the WMF wiki, no matter how
few there are of them.
It would be wounderful, but not feasable I think. Most of
international organizations limit their official language into a
number we can count by our two hands. Their regional branches issue
publifications in the regional languages, but those two - official
publification from the organisation itself and local publification
from its branch or sister organizations - are different matters.
One aspect of Wikimedia projects is that we have linguistic resources
and individuals who are willing to translate content between many
different languages, perhaps many more than would typically be available
for most other multi-national organizations outside of perhaps ones
related to the United Nations.
That said, I would say that a reasonable metric in terms of a line to
draw and not require any further translations to more obscure languages
that are difficult to support would be the same as for new project
proposals:
http://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/New_project_policy#Interest_poll
The United Nations limits their "official languages" to just six:
English, French, Spanish, Russian, Chinese, and Arabic
If you don't speak one of those languages, UN interpreters won't help
you directly. This list is very obviously politically motived by UN
politics, but still, these languages alone cover most of the world in
some way or another.
Clearly, in terms of communications between chapters and the base users
of Wikimedia projects, it is important to offer information and
organizational information in multiple languages.
Remember, less than half of all Wikimedia content is written in English,
and that percentage that is in English is increasingly becoming smaller.
--
Robert Scott Horning