KTC, I don't mean this as a criticism of the election committee. I
mean this as a criticism of both the Wikipedia article, and the
MediaWiki page for the elections. It's simply not clear to voters how
their votes will be processed unless they are familiar with all sorts
of obscure equations. It doesn't take a committee, or a community to
see that is something that needs to be fixed.
-Dan
On Jun 1, 2008, at 6:47 PM, Kwan Ting Chan wrote:
On Sun, 2008-06-01 at 16:54 -0400, Dan Rosenthal
wrote:
It wasn't for me, and I was voting. That page
just says "You can do X
to rank your candidates. We'll pick em with the Schulze method" But
never actually says WHAT the schulze method is. It just says go view
the Wikipedia page, which for me was completely incomprehensible.
Actually you know where I found the best description, was on the
Condorcet voting article. It explains it in pretty basic terms, but I
think they could be generalized even farther:
-----
Rank candidates in terms of preference. First choice is 1, second is
2, etc. Unranked candidates have a rank of 100, which is the lowest
possible rank. You may give multiple candidates the same rank if you
choose.
Something along those lines are already in the interface.
When you submit your ballot, each candidate's
preference will be
compared with each other candidate's preference, to see which one
would win in a "one on one" race. The candidate that would win the
most "one on one races" is the winner. For example, If you ranked
candidates A,B,C,D in the order 1, 2, 3, 4, then A would be the
winner, because A beat out three other candidates (B,C,D). B would
beat 2 other candidates, C would beat 1, and D would not beat any.
In the event of a tie, where the system is unable to determine a
winner, the system will then drop the candidates who won by the
narrowest margins until there is a winner.
When I first modified the software & interface, I got criticised for
having _too much_ technical information in there that are confusing,
hard for translator to translate, ...... So it was toned down, now the
criticism is that there's not enough information there.
The community need to decide on which side it want to come down on and
stick to it.
KTC
--
Experience is a good school but the fees are high.
- Heinrich Heine
_______________________________________________
foundation-l mailing list
foundation-l(a)lists.wikimedia.org
Unsubscribe:
https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/foundation-l