Il giorno 08/feb/07, alle ore 21:23, Pedro Sanchez ha scritto:
I'll try to reword Gregory's argument since I
think it's still not
clear to you (and for what I see, most it: people).
1. On italy, you're allowed to publish with permission but not
under fair use.
2. So you can upload if you get permission
3. Once the file has been uploaded in italy with permission, USA
people can access it
4. Should the cirterion met, USA people can reuse the content under
fair use (since there, fair use applies no matter what the licencing
terms are (permission or not))
Ok, that's received.
BUT the permission grants use *only* under certain condition.
More specifically, quite *all* the permission say "You can use it,
but ONLY on it.wikipedia".
This is our permission, and this is our deal.
therefore he's suggesting you to tag your images
with the text
* This image has been published in Italy with permission (not under
nonexistent "italy fair use")
* This image *could* be used on some other countries as fair use where
those countries law allow it
Saying this, I'm "inviting" other people to use it *outside*
it.wikipedia.
This goes against our deal and our permission.
It's like when I have a gun and I leave it on a seat in the park: if
anyone use it, I'm legally in trouble.
(By the way: is it etical doing what are you saying? It's a dirty trick)
Am I right greg? Did I explain it correctly?
You've not said the phrase "You're paranoid", that could be a problem.
Gatto Nero