2012/10/8 Platonides platonides@gmail.com:
On 08/10/12 14:45, Tomasz Ganicz wrote:
Moreover - it puts files on lists which have moved heritage template to the relevant category. In case of Polish contest if the heritage has its own category we asked mass-uploaders to put the file into the category without heritage template in file description. See for axample:
http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Category:Jewish_cemetery_in_Cz%C4%99stocho...
IMHO the files should both have the relevant identifier and be in the category. If I came to the description page (eg. by Special:Search), I wouldn't know it was a monument without having to visit all its categories, which is impractical.
Yes.. I personally agree with you in 100%. I was even arguing to not do this in that way, but I failed to persuade our fellow Polish commoners. They decided several years ago to do it in that way - before WLM started and they are very bound to this idea, unfortunately.
Argh. So you basically made a new division inside the template parameter. I can compensate that in the code. I had no idea you were doing that.
Although there are multiple formats used: A-1834 z 11.08.2008 916 z 09.11.1984 1061 1101/92 z 14.04.1992 A/3102/78 i 79 147/Wlkp/A A.734 z 24.05.1993 1598-A z 23.11.1995
What is the identifier that should be extracted?
I think it should be taken evrything from the field "$2" + code of voivodship ($1). In our heritage template:
{{zabytek|$1|$2|$3}}
$1 = code of viovodship $2 = ID $3 = exact name of place where the monument is located
for example:
{{zabytek|SL|A- 397/86 z 5.06.1986|Częstochowa}}
The wizzard was forcing people to fill $1 and $2.
ID can have many different structures - usually it is the number + date but not always - so the best is just to take them as they are. The mess with id's is not our fault - they were simpy copied from the xls documents as provided by our National Heritage Institute. I know that the Institute is actually working on implementation of a new system of monument's IDs to make them unique and simpler but God knows when they will do it..