On Wed, Jun 11, 2008 at 3:31 PM, Andrew Gray shimgray@gmail.com wrote:
2008/6/11 Brian McNeil brian.mcneil@wikinewsie.org:
There is one issue from the GRU policy proposal I have ported from Wikipedia. It specifies that those with the right to view deleted contributions should not do so in order to disseminate the content of the deleted contributions to third parties.
How do we know? There is no log of who views deleted pages except for whatever Brion and the other devs can access. Do we need such a log?
For now, I think we can make do with simply asking people to be good. With a couple of exceptions, it's worked so far.
Incidentally, I'm a little confused. Does existing enwp policy explictly say that? I've always understood that looking up deleted content and passing it on is fine (and indeed vaguely encouraged in some cases), as long as that content was deleted because we didn't want it rather than because it's Inherently Nasty Stuff.
(This demonstrates the problem of making a rule to deal with bad cases: it can potentially impinge on a lot of trivial but perfectly acceptable cases...)
--
- Andrew Gray
andrew.gray@dunelm.org.uk
In most cases, administraters can and do disseminate deleted materials within the terms of the GFDL. Things that are libelous or copyright violations should not be so distributed, as well as a few other judgement calls probably, as the situation warrents.
WilyD