On Jan 6, 2008 7:06 AM, effe iets anders effeietsanders@gmail.com wrote:
2008/1/6, Ray Saintonge saintonge@telus.net:
Jussi-Ville Heiskanen wrote:
On 1/5/08, Brianna Laugher brianna.laugher@gmail.com wrote:
Before any meta arbcom could be formed it would definitely need a strong definition of its jurisdiction.
I just wanted to make a comment for consideration about electing people to it. I may not be the only person concerned that it would be a strong concentration of power, and therefore a magnet to those who seek power, and that the people who most should be on it may be discouraged from actually participating due to the politics it will attract.
Yet another reason why having a meta arbcom that only operates in English, would be a tragic mistake.
There are certainly several major concerns about starting up the metarbcom, not the least of which defining itself. Perhaps the Wikicouncil should be established first, granted its authority in a slow and safe manner. Somewhere along the way it could be given the task of developping the metarbcom.
Ec
I think that the community as a whole should discuss this issue, and should come up with a proposal. Of course, if the community does not come to a conclusion, and is not able to come to such a proposal, it could ask a group of people to write one. However, I am not sure if I'd prefer to have writing these policies within the scope of the Volunteer Council/Wikicouncil. But that is a whole other discussion, in another thread on this list :)
However, you could also take any subgroup to write such a proposal.
BR, Lodewijk
I think having the discussion with the Community is what we are starting to do now.
Many people see the value of having a Wikicouncil/Voulunteer Council and also an independent body functioning as a meta-arbcom. There seems to be some users with concerns about the way these groups will be designed. I think the best way to answer these concerns is through thoughtful discussions with the community through each step in the process of starting these bodies. I'm pretty sure that it is possible to formulate a design that answers the concerns once they are brought to light.
Sydney