On 25 February 2013 09:40, James Alexander jamesofur@gmail.com wrote:
Err .... ok, I'm sorry but this actually moves to the realms of scary. You require the new Council member to send in a statement ... pledging loyalty essentially? I don't see anything in the charter that would require something like that, is it in your remit as chair? Sadly that just sounds like a way to force out reformers, if you don't support the charter you can't join the council? How do you expect to get things to change when necessary?
The charter is very basic. If you want to turn the organization upside down, throw away the charter or sack the Chair, it's very easy, you just put forward a resolution. The wording on http://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikimedia_Chapters_Association/Membership is: :"Declare that your chapter, and the appointed Council Member, respect the WCA Charter."
If you fundamentally disagree with the existence of the WCA, then it would be odd to join it. I believe it is entirely possible to join the WCA with the ambition of changing it, in fact I would love for more Council members to join with reformation agendas as it would bring plenty of energy into discussions.
As for scary, well, I can't comment, many folks seem to find me scary which puzzles me immensely.
Cheers, Fae