Commenting generally (i.e. not specifically to Risker), this topic has been giving me enough of a headache that I would like to see some kind of path forward, preferably one with the most harmony. I suggest that what should happen based on my admittedly not-detailed look at the draft's history and present state is that the whole document should go forward with an RfC. After that happens, I hope we'll all have enough clarity about the document to figure out what should happen next.
Personally, I'm kind of tired of this topic and would like to move on with something that is less contentious.
I do want some kind of behavior policy for Phabricator in particular. I'm not sure that it's this one as it's currently written, but I'm more concerned at this point about procedure than substance. Whatever the outcome of an RfC on the whole document is, I'd suggest accepting it and moving forward from there.
Pine