On 5/2/05, Dovi Jacobs dovijacobs@yahoo.com wrote:
When it came to the issue of audio file formats, for instance, Jimbo Wales made a very clear and correct decision that only file formats that could legally be used in free software would be allowed. Many tens of thousands of Wikimedia users would probably have liked to have been allowed to upload MP3 files. If an open vote had been held, MP3 would probably have been allowed. But no vote was held, because this is a fundamental Wikimedia policy.
Now, that's an interesting point. IF this were really the point, I MIGHT just give up. You say that MP3 cannot be "legally used in free software". So, what is going on? Is it indeed not used in free software? In that case I agree with not including it. Or is it used, but do we say that's illegal? In that case I still think we should shut up and just allow it. The issue should be availability, not politics. Especially not politics that noone else seems to care about.
Andre Engels