jamesmikedupont@googlemail.com wrote:
Sorry, But my question is not if we as a wikimedia group is violating the license, but if they as users are. I would like a professional opinion on the question :
Is wikipedia non commercial or commercial non profit?
It makes no difference. Wikipedia licenses everything on for commercial use. As you cannot relicense someone else's work, you cannot use a NC license worked. Most NC licensees probably wouldn't mind wikipedia reusing stuff, but they don't want big media reusing it.