Benjamin Webb wrote:
The main reason I think that becoming a WIkimedia project would be a good idea is the recognisation. The 'Wikimedia project' logo would bring credebility to the site.
The software at rodovid.org is quite impressive and interesting. Genealogy is a very popular hobby. However, most amateur genealogists that I know only research their own family, and within their family they are the only genealogist. While they can show their findings to interested family members, and share experience with fellow genealogists, the actual work is very lonely. There seems to be very little room for wiki-like, community-wide cooperation. It's more like a thousand bloggers, each writing their own blog, than any kind of cooperation.
There could be exceptions to this. The first example I stumbled on in the English branch of rodovid.org was Charles Darwin, the biologist. Researching the genealogy of famous persons, nobelty or royals, even though they are not your own family, can be an area for wiki-style cooperation.
For a genealogic project to reach the world-wide status that Wikipedia has as an encyclopedia, it would be necessary to try to catalog every person alive and dead. This is akin to what the Latter Day Saints (Mormons) try to do. They have pioneered the microfilming of historic population records and censuses around the world, and there are now several initiatives to try to put some of these microfilms online as facsimile images. OCR just doesn't work on old hand-written records, so it would be necessary to manually transcribe the text from the images. And then you would have to question the reliability of the old written records, in a way that most amateur genealogists fail to do. This is not going to happen within the next several decades, at least not on any larger scale. But you could try to do it for a limited area and period of time, such as a single small town or a handful of countryside parishes. So instead of just building Charles Darwin's family tree on rodovid.org, try to cover every family tree between 1750 and 1850 in the town Shrewsbury in Shropshire, England, where he was born in 1809. The town has 70,059 inhabitants today, and it should have been smaller back then. The number of people you have to map are quite within the reasonable size of a Mediawiki installation. When you're done you can expand to cover more towns or more centuries.
Perhaps I'm trying to say that it would be premature to adopt rodovid.org as an official Wikimedia project. My best bet would be to market it as a software package to amateur genealogists, or perhaps provide it as a (subscriber) service like blogger.com or wikicities.com.
I'm not speaking for the foundation, only for myself.