On 10/09/2011 07:20 PM, Thomas Dalton wrote:
The community doesn't trust the WMF at the moment. A firm commitment not to go against an overwhelming community opinion would go a long way towards fixing that.
That's exactly the situation. Right now, we're in a deadlock: WMF is waiting for the community to engange in a constructive dialog, forming new ideas and consensus. The community members* are waiting for a signal of trust by the WMF, a real recognition of their opposition, a clear statment that WMF and the community are on a par in this discussion and neither will do anything deemed unacceptable by the other, before they will rethink their own position.
You know, it's hard to lead a constructive discussion on controversial content when half of the people are thinking about forking. Believe me, I've tried.**
--Tobias
* that is, most of the opposing community members ** http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:2011-09-11_Podiumsdiskussion_Bildfilt...