2007/9/11, Thomas Dalton thomas.dalton@gmail.com:
It all boils down to "the spirit of the license". As long as we don't violate the spirit of the license (which we don't), we should be fine. If not legally, then at least morally.
I don't agree. Either we keep to the license, or we don't. If we don't, then we don't have a moral right to force others to keep to the license either. And then we would do better to switch to CC-BY-SA, or to write our own license that does state what we really want others and ourselves to do.
If we have the right to publish things under the GFDL as if they were licensed under CC-BY-SA, then we cannot deny others the right to republish them under CC-BY-SA either.