2011/11/2 Dominic McDevitt-Parks mcdevitd@gmail.com:
On 2 November 2011 00:40, Yann Forget yannfo@gmail.com wrote:
Hello,
Indeed, you are right. This is a great addition to Commons. I am going through it now, and I have questions.
In some cases, I found that there are better quality images than the ones we have. Where do they come from?
http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Joan_Baez_Bob_Dylan.jpg This version is of higher resolution than the original TIFF
http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Civil_Rights_March_on_Washington,_D.C...
http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Washakie.jpg This version is of much better quality, but lower resolution, than the original TIFF
http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Washakie_(Shoots-the-Buffalo-Running)...
It seems that the TIFF is not directly available, or I am dumb http://arcweb.archives.gov/arc/action/ExternalIdSearch?id=530875
Yes, in fact, in *all* cases the TIFFs being uploaded are better quality than the ones we have. :-)
No. I just showed 2 examples of the opposite.
As the Wikipedian in Residence, I have obtained the actual master files, which were never before made available to the public or on the online catalog. These are the files I am uploading, making Commons the only place you can find this NARA high-res content anywhere. I am also uploading a JPG version to go along with each TIFF. One consequence is that we'll need some help resolving the duplicates that this is generating, since there are thousands of the old scaled-down images on Commons and used in articles, but we can't replace them with superior quality versions until someone has gone through and made the matching edits (cropping, color correction, etc.) to the new ones that were made to the old ones.
Most images need a restoration. But we can do that now that we have high resolution TIFF. Obviously it will take years to do all this.
In cases of art work, we have black and white images, where the original was in color. Would it be possible to have a color version?
http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:%22Pilate_Washing_Hands_and_Feet%22,_...
That is the way that series was scanned. It is unknown why (these are from the '90s), but it should be noted that these are merely scans of prints of the original artworks, in any case. This set is also a special case, where they were donated to the institution; while NARA has a lot of graphic works (like the war posters), most of it is not purely artistic in origin, since they are US federal records.
OK.
Dominic
Yann