Perhaps the person who has a lot of money to donate wants to help the WMF to get even more money than if he had just donated it anonymously. Products tend to be greater than sums, so if there's a way for us to multiply instead of add, then we get more money. You're wrong that money isn't important- with more money, we could afford more servers and be more reliable and faster.
On 11/9/06, lars lars@aronsson.se wrote:
James Forrester wrote:
One particularly powerful way in which we can increase funds is to see if we can get "matching donation" - that is for every x units, so-and-so promises to donate y, up to a limit.
[...] I think that a line (in the site notice), saying something like "Foo have pledged to match up to US$200,000 in our [[current fund-raising drive]]" instead of the current text ("Your [[continued donations]] keep Wikipedia running!") would
First Jimbo's $100 million and now this. I must warn against spending too much time thinking about money. If you like money, do business. Money is not what brought me here. Money is an idea that infests your brain, and after a while you start to think that you cannot do anything if you don't have money. That is a trap. Wikipedia is and should be a monument to how much good can in fact be done with almost no money.
I do not agree that matching donations increase funds. If someone has $200 thousand to spend, let them donate it without waiting for a match. Their donation is added to everybody else's. That's simple addition, not a multiplication.
So, why would anybody want to do a matching donation rather than just silently submit what they have? To get their name and logotype displayed? If they want this kind of display, tell them to buy advertising from companies that sell advertising space. If they want to help Wikipedia, the way to do so is to donate. There are lots of people who silently donate. Why should WMF give special treatment to people who want to make this process more complicated? If silent donors don't get this special treatment, why should they continue to be silent?
-- Lars Aronsson (lars@aronsson.se) Aronsson Datateknik - http://aronsson.se _______________________________________________ foundation-l mailing list foundation-l@wikimedia.org http://mail.wikipedia.org/mailman/listinfo/foundation-l