On 4/23/07, David Gerard dgerard@gmail.com wrote:
How about using the old domain, wikipedia.com, as a site for stable Wikipedia versions, with ads on? The ad money, as well as paying our comparatively small hosting and staff costs, could go toward educational programmes for those people who could benefit from our hard work but *aren't* comfortable, well-fed first-world citizens.
This idea seems to inevitably lead towards a sharp distinction between a "for readers" Wikipedia and a "for editors" Wikipedia. I'm not convinced that distinction is helpful, rather, I would try to work to make the current editorial processes of Wikipedia more transparent (this is the main thing stable version functionality provides: transparency about what it is you are looking it).
A very simple change in this direction, for example, would be to have a little banner for any page that has been touched less than an hour ago:
"This Wikipedia article has been edited very recently. Wikipedia is _a work in progress_ that can be edited by anyone. Please review our disclaimers before using information presented here."
Again, more transparency, more information to the reader about what Wikipedia _is_. The interests of the encyclopedia come before any money-making opportunities, and I'm not convinced that the .com/.org split would help these interests. I am, in fact, concerned that it would lead to more confusion and division.
Now, that said, one advertising-related idea that has been discussed and not completely shouted down is a kind of "opt-out" advertising which is opt-in by default for readers, and opt-out by default for registered users. I'm not convinced it is necessary either, but it seems like the most sensible gradual next step. But as for all the great programs that ads could support, how about we spec these out and budget them first, and try to raise funds for them the old-fashioned non-profit way? I find it, for lack of a better word, asinine to justify ads with all the great things we could do if we had money. Shouldn't we have a much better idea of what these great things are _before_ we try to get more money?