Hello,
Marco brings up one wiki that flourished without meeting these requirements (it predates them), but I can give a very large number of examples of projects that *didn't* flourish. Some interesting pages to see are < http://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Proposals_for_closing_projects
and < http://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Inactive_wikis >. So far as I
know, no new wiki since the subcommittee was formed has become inactive yet.
Just to make it sure, the numbers in the table are obsolete, right? For instance, I see that in the table the closure of Lak Wikipedia stands as 7 to 1, whereas in reality it is 7 to 10 (the other 9 votes were cast after some revival of the project).
Cheers, Yaroslav