On 21/09/13 15:53, Mykola Kozlenko wrote:
Hi Yaroslav and Maarten,
I've had a look at https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Category:Cultural_heritage_monuments_in_U... , and I have found three different types of images "blocking" your bot:
- images with definitely wrong IDs, e.g.
https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:AbDSC_1833.jpg
- images without any IDs, like
https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Ukrainian_Anthem.jpg
- images with IDs starting with 99 - those participate in
partner-sponsored contests (e.g. Armenian monuments in Ukraine, Greek monuments in Ukraine) but do not appear in the monument database as they are not on the national heritage lists - e.g. https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:%D0%86%D0%BD%D1%82%D0%B5%D1%80%27%D1...
Is there any way to sort them to separate categories based on these criteria? This would greatly facilitate our work of sorting them out.
Sure, to which categories should each be moved?
When is an ID “definitely wrong”?
You only seem to have a few wrong identifiers, though: http://toolserver.org/~platonides/wlm2013/uploads.php?country=ua&type=ba...
But ~400 with no id: http://toolserver.org/~platonides/wlm2013/uploads.php?country=ua&type=em...
These are the big chunk waiting to be categorized.
Finally, there are 18 images with an id starting with 99:
Інтер'єр_костелу_станом_на_травень_2009р._(ракурс_1).JPG | Інтер'єр_костелу_станом_на_травень_2009р._(ракурс_2).JPG | Костел_вірменський_1764р..JPG | Інтер'єр_костелу_станом_на_травень_2009р._(ракурс_3).JPG | Інтер'єр_костелу_станом_на_травень_2009р._(ракурс_4).JPG | Belltower_of_St._Nicholas_Church._Kamianets-Podilskyi.JPG | Church_of_St._Nicholas._Kamianets-Podilskyi.JPG | Церква_Сурб_Геворг.JPG | Церква_Сурб_Геворг_Миколаїв.JPG | Церква_Сурб_Геворг_2.JPG | Хачкар_біля_церкви_Сурб_Геворг_Миколаїв.JPG | Церква_Сурб_Геворг_у_Миколаєві.JPG | Церква_Сурб_Геворг._Архітектор_Попов_В.,_Миколаїв,.JPG | Церковь_Сурб-Рипсиме..jpg | The_Armenian_Church_of_St._Resurrection_in_Kharkiv_1.jpg | The_Armenian_Church_of_St._Resurrection_in_Kharkiv_2.jpg | The_Armenian_Church_of_St._Resurrection_in_Kharkiv_3.jpg | The_cross-stone_of_Armenian_Church_of_St._Resurrection_in_Kharkiv.JPG