2012/9/5 Platonides platonides@gmail.com:
On 05/09/12 00:14, Béria Lima wrote:
Not even give a link to the picture in the land page (for sake of following the license?)
Is quite strange to fight copyvio and then do not follow the license in the picture we use in the banner. _____ /Béria Lima/
He's the author and has given a reasonable objection to the way we are using the file*. I'd remove it and replace with a new file made by us. Using some WLM 2011 pictures for instance (even though we should still provide some credit).
(* Actually I think Newton2 deserves more credit than Saibo for that picture, even though the photo shadows are cool, but both should be theoretically credited, plus Paulrudd and Mikel Ortega, whose photos -embedded in the original file albeit mostly hidden on the thumb- are not CC-BY compatible)
Exactly :-) Honesty - I don't see anything creative in puting other person picture on top of the file and just shift and add some shadow... But anyway - WLM logo is under CC-BY-SA 3.0 - so using this logic we violate also copyright of this:
https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:LUSITANA_WLM_2011_d.svg
and in fact even harder :-) It is not credited on our banner but also on pencils, buttons, T-shirts etc... I guess some direct agreement from Lusitan is needed to be signed with WLM organisers...