On Thu, 22 Sep 2011 09:11:50 +0200, Jane Darnell jane023@gmail.com wrote:
Romaine, I am afraid this can't be fixed before September 30, no matter how hard
you
may try! You may be able to categorize these photos and "undelete" them next year if and when you get legislation passed, but what you are talking
about
is really way too complicated for our little contest to handle (but publicizing this problem in the Belgian newspapers may help!!!). I was astounded to find that this problem also exists in France. good luck, Jane
The problem exists as well in Italy, some Scandinavian countries, many of the East European countries, and, as far as I understand, it was one of the main barriers which delayed the participation of Russia. The best practice is actually not to delete the pictures but to transfer them to the projects as fair use (obviously, it could only be done in the projects which accept fair use, German and Spanish Wikipedias do not qualify).
Cheers Yaroslav
2011/9/21 Romaine Wiki romaine_wiki@yahoo.com
Hello all,
Today several pictures that were uploaded for Wiki Loves Monuments in Belgium which are considered monuments by the Belgian government have been deleted because we do not have a clear description on Commons about the copyright-situation in Belgium on buildings that are younger than 70 years (or architect died less then 70 years ago). If this continues thousands of pictures on Commons can be deleted on some vague text that seems to be based on what people do not understand about the copyright in Belgium.
The Belgian laws on this matter are complicated and we should urgently get a more clear picture of how the actual copyright laws should be conducted.
I think we can get a clear picture if we consult Belgian a lawyer(s)
who
can handle this subject. I have two questions:
- Who knows a lawyer or firm who/which can help us with the question
how
the Belgian law actually is on this matter?
- If this will cost anything, who can help us with funding to get this
answer clear?
Who can help us with this or has ideas about it?
Other ideas are also very welcome!
Greetings - Romaine
(Organizing Wiki Loves Monuments Belgium / Luxembourg) (Intitiave for organizing Wikimedia belgium)
Wiki Loves Monuments mailing list WikiLovesMonuments@lists.wikimedia.org https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikilovesmonuments http://www.wikilovesmonuments.eu